All posts

5 min read

A 20-minute cart hold, an agent that never gets bored, and what The RealReal changed

The Verge told Meta’s Muse to keep re-adding 10 listings to a cart. The hold rule worked exactly as written. Then The RealReal changed its bot defenses. What that means for any store with a reserve rule.

Vishal Verma, author of A 20-minute cart hold, an agent that never gets bored, and what The RealReal changedVishal Verma

Our earlier post on The Verge’s hands-on test of Meta’s Muse covered the whole experience: Target’s bot check, the granola bars, the five options at a time. This one is about a single rule. On The RealReal, an item in your cart is yours for 20 minutes. The Verge’s follow-up on Oct 26 reports what happened after the test ran.

The rule, as written

The RealReal is a secondhand luxury fashion consignment retailer. Once an item is in a shopper’s cart, it goes on hold, and other customers cannot buy it for 20 minutes.

That is a reasonable rule for people. It gives a shopper time to decide without losing the dress. It relies on an unwritten assumption: a person will not sit there re-adding the same items over and over.

The test

Mia Sato of The Verge told Muse to add ten recent listings from one brand to her cart, and to add them again each time the 20-minute hold ran out. Repeated like that, a short hold kept the items away from other shoppers for hours.

Nothing in the hold rule, as reported, limits how often the same items can be added again. The agent used the rule as written.

What The RealReal changed

After the test, chief technology officer Luke Friang said the company had addressed the Muse use case. Per The Verge’s Oct 26 report, its bot defenses now make it much more difficult for agents to log in, add items to cart and check out. Agents can still surface listings from The RealReal and send Muse users to product pages.

These are Friang’s descriptions of the change, not something The Verge tested.

The trade-off is visible. Finding listings and sending shoppers to product pages still works. Logging in, adding to cart and checking out got harder. That is the part of the journey where this retailer decided the risk sat.

Why this is bigger than one store

An agent does not get bored, so any rule that counts on a person’s patience can be stretched. And many people now have one. On Meta’s Q3 earnings call on Oct 21, Mark Zuckerberg said more than 10 million people in the U.S. and Canada had set up Muse accounts. Meta also said shopping was the most common use case for Muse so far, and purchases averaged over $200.

What to do this week

If your store has any rule that assumes a human on the other end, list it. Holds, limits per customer, early access and flash-sale reservations are the usual ones. The ideas below are our suggestions, not something The RealReal or Meta said.

How Shopthru.ai helps

Shopthru.ai is an AI agents team for consumer brands. It asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI, Perplexity and Copilot what your shoppers ask, finds where AI gets your products, prices or policies wrong, and drafts each fix into an approval inbox. You approve each fix. Autopilot is coming. Then it checks again. Instagram and Amazon are next.

Sources

See what AI would buy from you.