All posts

5 min read

80% of merchants call AI visibility a priority. None selling through their own site or app can fully tie AI visits to sales.

A PYMNTS survey of 60 US merchants finds brands working hard to show up in AI, but none selling on their own site or app can fully follow an AI visit to a purchase. Here is what that gap means and a simple way to start closing it.

Vishal Verma, author of 80% of merchants call AI visibility a priority. None selling through their own site or app can fully tie AI visits to sales.Vishal Verma

Brands are spending on showing up in AI answers. Most cannot yet see what that work sells.

What the survey found

PYMNTS Intelligence surveyed 60 senior eCommerce decision-makers at US merchants with $50 million to $1 billion in yearly revenue. PYMNTS covered the report, “The Agent Advantage”, on Nov 3.

  • 80% call AI visibility a high or critical priority. 62% say the same about identifying AI-driven visits and purchases.
  • 87% have taken at least one step to improve how their products appear in AI platforms.
  • No surveyed merchant selling through its own site or app can fully and consistently connect AI-driven visits to completed purchases.

Where the trail goes cold

  • 51% see some AI-originated visits, but their attribution is inconsistent.
  • 37% of those selling on their own site or app spotted an AI visit, then lost the trail before purchase.
  • 12% cannot tell agentic traffic from human traffic.

So the work is happening, but the scoreboard is missing. A brand can fix its product pages for AI and still not know if any of it led to a sale.

Why it matters

PYMNTS makes the point plainly: connecting AI referrals to completed orders would let retailers compare AI investments and judge partnerships.

It also adds a fair warning. Attribution needs care, since an AI touch on a journey does not by itself prove an extra sale.

A simple scoreboard to start with

You do not need perfect attribution to learn something. Start with what you can control: what AI says about you, before and after each fix.

  1. Pick the 20 questions your shoppers ask most.
  2. Ask each AI assistant and record whether you are named, and whether the facts are right.
  3. Make one fix at a time, and note the date.
  4. Ask the same questions again after the fix.
  5. Line up those dates with your AI referral traffic and orders. Treat any link as a clue, not proof.

Limits

  • It is a survey of 60 merchants, all in the US and all mid-sized to large.
  • We read PYMNTS’s article on the report, not the full report.
  • Survey answers are what merchants say, not measured tracking.

How Shopthru AI helps

Shopthru AI is an AI agents team for consumer brands. It asks ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI, Perplexity and Copilot what your shoppers ask, finds where AI gets your products, prices or policies wrong, and drafts each fix into an approval inbox. You approve each fix. Autopilot is coming. Then it checks again. Instagram and Amazon are next.

Sources

See what AI would buy from you.